Reaper

Reaper - CW

The Backstory: Dude’s folks sold his soul; now that he’s 21, he’s Satan’s bounty hunter, vastly improving his résumé.

The Elevator Pitch: American Pie’s Sherminator cops a plea with The Devil’s Advocate.

The Good: Smart writing; likable leads; did we mention the soul-sucking hand vac?

The Bad: Could be too kitschy for its own good

The Verdict: Don’t you dare miss it—or we’ll sic Satan on you.